Arizona Oddities

Main Menu

  • Home
  • Your Guides
  • Departments
    • Art
    • Dose of History
    • Culture
    • Natural Surroundings
    • Odd Observations
    • Weather Talk
    • Food & Dining
    • Small Town Scene
    • Recreation
    • Only in Arizona
  • Get the Books
  • Contact Us

logo

Arizona Oddities

  • Home
  • Your Guides
  • Departments
    • Art
    • Dose of History
    • Culture
    • Natural Surroundings
    • Odd Observations
    • Weather Talk
    • Food & Dining
    • Small Town Scene
    • Recreation
    • Only in Arizona
  • Get the Books
  • Contact Us
Odd ObservationsValley of the Sun
Home›Odd Observations›Scottsdale’s Planet Ranch a Costly Goof

Scottsdale’s Planet Ranch a Costly Goof

By Andrea Aker
April 29, 2010
3285
1

Excerpt from Valley 101: A Slightly Skewed Guide to Living in Arizona, a collection of Clay Thompson’s columns for The Arizona Republic. (Originally published April 1, 2001.)

Q: We were exploring some back roads in western Arizona when we came to a locked gate with a sign reading, “Planet Ranch, City of Scottsdale.” What is Scottsdale doing in La Paz County?

A: Ah, Planet Ranch.We’d forgotten about that, and there probably are a lot of people in Scottsdale who wish they could forget about it, too. It is one of those “seemed like a good idea at the time” things, the type of thing, we must admit, that checkers the careers of many Valley 101 staff members.

In 1984, Scottsdale paid $11.7 million for the 171,141-acre Planet Ranch in order to gain the rights to water from the Bill Williams River. The idea was to build a pipeline to carry the river water to the Central Arizona Project Canal and thence to Scottsdale.

Scottsdale was not alone in this speculation. Mesa and Phoenix also bought “water farms,” and developers were abuzz with plans to buy up tracts of land and peddle the water rights to cities.

However, in a rare burst of cogent thinking, the Legislature realized these schemes could drain rural parts of the state of their water rights. So new laws were passed that sharply limited such enterprises, and the water-ranchers, most notably Scottsdale, were left holding the bag. Not a drop of the Bill Williams ever bedewed Scottsdale.

At the time, the rules required that to retain the water rights, the land had to be farmed, so Scottsdale went into the alfalfa business, with a notable lack of success. In 1993, the city spent $1.18 million on Planet Ranch and earned $626,341 selling alfalfa. This, as they say, is no way to run a railroad.

A few offers to buy the land have come and gone, and changes in the law have lifted the alfalfa bale from Scottsdale’s back, but the ranch remains a property of the city of the West’s Most Western City.

(Visited 811 times, 2 visits today)

Related Posts:

  1. The Stories Behind Scottsdale’s McCormick Ranch, Gainey Ranch
  2. Scottsdale Shopping Center Becomes the Right Place for a Wright Piece
  3. Why Does the Valley Have a Canal System, and How Does it Work?
  4. Legend City: A Failure in Its Own Era
  5. Creation Painted at El Coronado Ranch
Tagsscottsdale

1 comment

  1. SaraD 22 April, 2012 at 09:04 Reply

    At just about the time the ranch got started, the bottom dropped out of the horse market – the Arabian horse market, in particular. Contributing factor: IRS rule changes that disallowed “hobby” horse farming as a tax deduction (a good thing). Arabian horse ranches in Scottsdale began moving out or shutting down, and the city offered no incentive keep them here because developers wanted the land they occupied and the city wanted that always-of-primary-importance tax revenue from it. By the early 1990s, there were fewer horses in the area. That meant fewer mouths to eat hay and hay-based products. That meant hay sales that were lower than anticipated by Planet Ranch. Those of us who had horses here in the Valley hoped for low hay prices from that “local” source. It never happened. You could buy Colorado hay for less than you could Planet Ranch hay. Throw in that new legislation that protected water rights (a good thing). The whole deal was in the wrong place at the wrong time and there were just way too many “bean counters” involved. IMO

Leave a reply Cancel reply

Arizona Oddities Archive

Most Popular Posts

  • How to Keep Scorpions Away from Your Home
  • How to Keep Javelinas Away from Your Yard
  • What’s With All the Backyard Concrete-Block Fences…
  • Did You Know it’s Against the Law to Grow…
  • Can You Get a Sunburn Under Water?

This Week Past Years

2020

  • Scottsdale is Home to Frank Lloyd Wright’s Desert-Inspired Winter Haven

2017

  • Mid-Century Modern Architecture Still Vibrant in Phoenix

2016

  • An Educated Ghost Lost on Campus

2015

  • Get a Whiff of This Old Arizona Party Spot

2014

  • Hear the Balladeer's Ballads at Arizona Folklore Preserve

2013

  • Featured Artist: Pete the Miner
  • Abraham Lincoln’s Bodyguard and Other Civil War Soldiers Buried in Southern Arizona

2012

  • Celebrating the Centennial (sort of) with a Message, Compilation from Clay Thompson
  • Celebrating the Centennial: 10 People that Shaped Arizona
  • Celebrating the Centennial: My Long Distance Love Affair With Arizona
  • Billy Stiles: Lawman-Outlaw-Lawman

2011

  • Trivia on Arizona Cities & Towns: Can You Pass?

2010

  • Doc Flower: One of Old Arizona’s Great Con Men
  • Recent

  • Popular

  • Comments

  • Find a Famous Writer and Explorer's Mountain Retreat in Greer

    Find a Famous Writer and Explorer’s Historic Mountain Retreat in Greer

    By Taylor Haynes
    July 31, 2020
  • thousands of Mexican free tail bats make Phoenix tunnel their summer home

    Thousands of Mexican Free-Tail Bats Make Phoenix Tunnel Their Summer Home

    By Taylor Haynes
    July 17, 2020
  • How to Keep Scorpions Away from Your Home

    By Andrea Aker
    January 3, 2011
  • Javelina

    How to Keep Javelinas Away from Your Yard

    By Andrea Aker
    November 23, 2011
  • Phil Motta
    on
    August 27, 2021

    Why Does Downtown Phoenix Seem to Have Two Downtowns?

    I know this post ...
  • Carol
    on
    October 17, 2020

    The Tucson Artifacts are the Southwest’s Greatest Hoax

    lol ... these "clues" ...

Follow us

© Copyright 2009 – 2023 Aker Ink, LLC :: Arizona Oddities is published by Aker Ink.